Be confident in your staff’s ability to reduce risk by providing compliance training that changes behavior.
View All ProductsDevelop next-level people for next-level care by prioritizing quality and safety improvements.
View All ProductsEstablish a culture of belonging with education supporting DEI, wellness, engagement, and leadership development.
View All ProductsDeliver custom or industry designed product training directly to patient and resident care environments to reinforce proper use.
View All ProductsHealthStream offers performance learning management solutions to help develop your healthcare staff into leaders and reduce turnover.
View All ProductsHealthStream works with healthcare organizations to create engaging and high-quality training videos for your staff and management.
View All ProductsImprove care quality and save money by making informed decisions about your healthcare facility and staff with HealthStream's reporting analytics solution.
View All ProductsHealthStream's proven methods for the improvement and overall engagement of your healthcare staff foster a positive workplace and increase retention rates.
View All ProductsStop wasting money on RCM issues. Learn how to Provide your team with expert-led revenue cycle training to help them reduce denied claims, reimbursement mistakes, and more.
View All ProductsTackle all the challenges of provider directory management within a health plan with a single solution tailored to your specific needs.
View All ProductsOur affordable CVO credentialing services establish patient safety by enabling primary source verification for your healthcare organization.
View All ProductsFinally, a comprehensive resource to support collecting, storing, and sharing credentialing data with ease.
View All ProductsIntegrate with Epic to validate and add new providers directly to your provider master file.
View All ProductsLearn about our advanced resuscitation training solutions. Our solutions are designed to help improve patient outcomes.
View All ProductsOur competency development solutions personalize learning for clinicians to bridge the gap between theory and practice for your nurse residents.
View All ProductsEnhance maternal & child nursing care with solutions focused on improving the quality of care for mothers, infants, and children.
View All ProductsAddress staffing orientation challenges to easily achieve and maintain certification with our emergency and acute care training solutions.
View All ProductsAs a premier provider of healthcare education, we are committed to promoting safer, more successful surgical and sedation outcomes for each and every patient.
View All ProductsOur solutions are designed to cater to the needs of patients, healthcare professionals, and organizations dealing with illnesses or chronic conditions.
View All ProductsHealthcare workforce management is essential. We provide advanced scheduling solutions for organizations to solve issues such as nurse retention
View All ProductsMitigate risk and elevate your quality of care. Improving both clinical and business outcomes starts with a smarter, more integrated approach to regulatory training, continuing education and quality management.
Learn MoreIn the history of the impact of conflicts of interest (COI) in healthcare, the rise and fall of arthritis pain drug Vioxx was a watershed event. All the elements were there: a major drug company study, incomplete reporting of data by drug company employees, data oversight by someone with at least the appearance of a financial COI, and a failure to disclose adverse effects of the drug. Even the FDA bore some responsibility.
The resulting scandal damaged the reputation of the New England Journal of Medicine and Merck, an admired pharmaceutical company. Vioxx cost Merck over $5 billion in settlements.
An FDA whistleblower stated that 60,000 people died from heart attacks in the five years before Merck voluntarily withdrew the drug in late 2004. COI—even the appearance of COI—has the potential to seriously harm patients and damage healthcare institutions.
Not All COIs Result in Biased Decision-Making
COI exists when a person could derive personal benefit from actions or decisions made in his or her official capacity, but do all COIs require redress? According to Bill Sacks, co-founder of HCCS, “Relationships among physicians, hospitals and the medical industry are important. Industry contributes to medical education, funds clinical trials, and provides medications for the indigent. In short, they support the teaching, research and clinical missions of academic medicine.”
Typically, only 8 – 12 percent of disclosures require review by the compliance department or an internal COI committee, and only 1 – 2 percent may need recusal from decision-making or divestiture of stock. A potential COI disclosure risk, therefore, is the possibility of “throwing the baby out with the bathwater.” On the other hand, failure to adequately address COI exposes institutions and patients to risk.
Managing COI Risk
Regulatory compliance requires that healthcare organizations secure annual conflict of interest disclosures from physicians, APPs, board members, and hospital leaders at the director level and above. Effective disclosure requires a thorough questionnaire to guide discernment of any conflicts. The questionnaire must walk individuals through their business relationships, revealing the potential for COI. Conflicts must then be reported on a disclosure form.
Perhaps a physician is influencing the purchase of a medical device. Is the doctor’s recommendation the best possible choice, or is it because he receives speaking fees from the device manufacturer? Are stents selected by a hospital the best choice for patients, or was the purchase influenced by the cath lab director’s relationship with the sales representative? A hospital board member is the sister of a bank’s CEO. Did this relationship influence the selection of the bank as a lender?
Unknown and undisclosed conflicts can threaten an institution’s tax-exempt status, reputation, research funding, and most importantly, patient safety.
When a Disclosure Requires Action
COI Policies should define the types of disclosures that require a management and mitigation plan. The plan should prescribe the steps the organization will take to mitigate any bias or appearance of bias. The institution could ask the individual with a conflict to reduce the value of a financial relationship so that it falls below a threshold amount designated by policy. The individual could be required to forgo participation in committee votes, deliberations, or decisions about a topic related to that individual’s conflict of interest.
For research projects, it may make sense to modify the design of the project or have an independent researcher serve as the principal investigator. Another approach could be to provide an observer to monitor and evaluate any appearance of bias in the decisions made or influenced by the individual.
Managing and Monitoring Disclosures
The compliance director or the compliance committee must review and vet annual COI disclosures. An automated system, with an online COI questionnaire, simplifies this process significantly and reduces the possibility of overlooking important disclosures. Paper and pencil disclosure forms are more difficult to manage within policy expectations and are more difficult to secure for confidentiality.
Proper vetting looks at a variety of risks, especially any possible influence on medical judgment. The process must include evaluating whether any compensation is for bona fide work and whether it reflects fair market value. Appropriate review will reveal whether referrals were expected because of any gift or compensation. Implementing an organized—and automated—process prevents surprises by proactively managing any questionable relationships.
If your organization is looking for an automated, single-platform solution for managing COI, visit hccs.com/COI for information about COI-SMART, a cloud-based platform offering custom questionnaire design, best practice advice, management plan templates, and relevant subject matter.
When you enact HealthStream's quality compliance solutions, you can do so with the confidence your healthcare organization will meet all standards of care.
View All Quality & ComplianceBe confident in your staff’s ability to reduce risk by providing compliance training that changes behavior.
View All ProductsDevelop next-level people for next-level care by prioritizing quality and safety improvements.
View All ProductsEstablish a culture of belonging with education supporting DEI, wellness, engagement, and leadership development.
View All ProductsHealthStream’s learning management system and healthcare training solutions support medical training initiatives and allow for the best patient care.
View All Learning & PerformanceHealthStream offers performance learning management solutions to help develop your healthcare staff into leaders and reduce turnover.
View All ProductsHealthStream works with healthcare organizations to create engaging and high-quality training videos for your staff and management.
View All ProductsImprove care quality and save money by making informed decisions about your healthcare facility and staff with HealthStream's reporting analytics solution.
View All ProductsHealthStream's proven methods for the improvement and overall engagement of your healthcare staff foster a positive workplace and increase retention rates.
View All ProductsUtilize patient access solutions and advanced reimbursement solutions to manage clinical denials and improve your organization’s reimbursement strategy.
View All ReimbursementComprehensive, industry-leading provider onboarding and credentialing software that validates health outcomes and supports provider assessment.
View All CredentialingOur affordable CVO credentialing services establish patient safety by enabling primary source verification for your healthcare organization.
View All ProductsIntegrate with Epic to validate and add new providers directly to your provider master file.
View All ProductsExpand the decision-making skills and effectiveness of your healthcare workforce with HealthStream's clinical development programs and services.
View All Clinical DevelopmentLearn about our advanced resuscitation training solutions. Our solutions are designed to help improve patient outcomes.
View All ProductsOur competency development solutions personalize learning for clinicians to bridge the gap between theory and practice for your nurse residents.
View All ProductsEnhance maternal & child nursing care with solutions focused on improving the quality of care for mothers, infants, and children.
View All ProductsAddress staffing orientation challenges to easily achieve and maintain certification with our emergency and acute care training solutions.
View All ProductsAs a premier provider of healthcare education, we are committed to promoting safer, more successful surgical and sedation outcomes for each and every patient.
View All ProductsOur solutions are designed to cater to the needs of patients, healthcare professionals, and organizations dealing with illnesses or chronic conditions.
View All ProductsMake sure your healthcare staff can schedule out appointments and work schedules with ease using HealthStream's line of software solutions.
View All SchedulingHealthcare workforce management is essential. We provide advanced scheduling solutions for organizations to solve issues such as nurse retention
View All Products